the 100 most memorable moments in soap history
Even ATWT purists sometimes need a cheat sheet to figure out how supercouple Holden & Lily (Jon Hensley & Martha Byrne) aren't related, and this moment is the reason why. In 1987, Iva Snyder (Margaret Brown) ran into the Snyder barn, thinking she was witnessing Josh Snyder (William Fichtner) assaulting Lily. In fact, Lily was just frantic about the apparent disappearance of Craig, but before Iva had realized that, she brandished a nearby pitchfork at Josh and exclaimed, "She's your baby!" With that, the cat was out of the bag: one of ATWT's biggest secrets was unveiled, and many of the show's central relationships were put to the emotional test afterwards.